09 | 17

Monkey see, monkey do

Categories: ACT Government, Discrimination/Racism, Ernst & Young, Former Commissioner, Government, Racism

by: Watershedd
Leave feedback | 30 Comments »

“Behead all those who insult the prophet!” So read the banner in Sydney on Saturday, in a protest ignited by a film released in the United States. Really, the lack of respect shown by the creators of the video and by the protestors are equally abysmal. One group insults another, the other feels it acceptable to damage the property of the place they have immigrated to and chosen to call home. And all of it is perpetuated by someone outside of our own shores. Remember, I told you Australia, the racism that underpins the narrow-mindedness of our national psyche and that erupted with the Cronulla riots in 2005 has never been properly dealt with. And here it is reaching a boil again, here it is right in front of our eyes. So much for all the efforts to address racial intolerance. Here we go, yet again and we really have no-one to blame but ourselves, for the double standard was set long ago and has continued unabated for over 200 years. Just last week a non-Indigenous man in his twenties was recounting his disgust at a man in Melbourne who had asked if he knew of any “whites only” hotels.

In January of 2004, the Australian Capital Territory’s (ACT) first and to date only Indigenous Commissioner of Revenue (aka ‘Pat’) was dismissed from the ACT Department of Treasury after a racially based campaign instigated by a Treasury employee identified on Blak and Black as the Inquisitor for his delving into Pat’s personal and employment history without justifiable legal cause or authority. His efforts were abetted by the inaction or purposeful misrepresentation of people within the ACT Department of Treasury, the Australian Federal Police, the Australian Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission and Ernst & Young. In delving into Pat’s past, the Inquisitor alleged that Pat had falsified his qualifications to attain the role of Commissioner of Revenue and produced copies of his supposed application to justify the racist invective within his letter of complaint of 9 May 2002:

“I have attached a copy of [Pat’s] applications for your information. [Pat] holds unrelated qualifications, being a Bachelor of Arts Degree and a Diploma in Education … I have discussed [Pat’s] background with Ms Tanya Taylor, Recruitment Consultant of Ernst & Young who has confirmed my assessment that Aborigines are compulsive liars and criminals and that [Pat’s] teaching qualification made him unsuitable to work at either Ernst & Young or ACT Treasury …

I request that [Pat] be dismissed from the ACT Public Service due to his unethical behaviour and the general disposition of Aborigines to lie and the criminal records of his family.”

The Inquisitor to Howard Ronaldson, Chief Executive, ACT Dept of Treasury

This letter of 9 May 2002 is of particular interest for several reasons. It states Pat’s actual qualifications at the time he was appointed to the role of Manager Policy, Legislation and Projects and subsequently to that of Director Revenue Management Branch (the substantive title of the role being Commissioner for Revenue). More importantly, it reflects and coincides with the letter of advice from Ernst & Young Partner Andrew McCrossin two years earlier dated 13 July 2000. Additionally, as Pat had been recruited to Ernst & Young by Tanya Taylor, who is dobbed in by the Inquisitor for bad-mouthing Aborigines in general, and as the letter from Ernst & Young (EY) itself demonstrates, he was in fact offered the role with his salary reduced in consideration of his lack of specific “… formal qualifications in law and accounting.”

Seventeen months later on 13 October 2003, Meredith Whitten, ACT Dept of Treasury Director, Corporate Services, penned the following to [Pat]:

Whitten to Pat, 13 October 2003 

Whitten to Pat, 13 October 2003

Notice anything unusal? Think about. I’ll wait … Pat’s qualifications are not listed.  The assumption must be made that no copies of Pat’s qualifications were held in his file at the time Meredith Whitten sent this communication to Pat.

“Ah I hear you say, but evidence of Pat’s qualifications were in the Inquisitor’s letter in 2002. How could that be so?” Indeed how could it be so, if they weren’t on his official ACT Department of Treasury file some seventeen months later? The only probable answer is that the qualifications the Inquisitor mentioned in his May 9, 2002 letter came from Pat’s Ernst and Young personnel file.

Interestingly, Pat was appointed internally by Tu Pham to the Commissioner’s position on a contractual basis without a formal interview process, initially for three months and subsequently renewed for varying periods on at least seven further occasions. Pat’s substantive and the role for which the ACT Department of Treasury maintained a personnel file for him, was that of Manager Policy, Legislation and Projects, to which he should have reverted had he not continued in the Commissioner’s role on a permanent basis. Of course, sour grapes at failing to succeed in rising to the role of Commisioner and racist intent can cause a black man to lose not only his contract, but his entire career. Just ask Pat’s family.

Intolerance indeed. Intolerance is what leads to the sorts of traumas that Pat and his family have suffered. Intolerance is what leads to Jill Courtney being stereotyped and victimized because she happened to subscribe to a religion others refused to respect, let alone try to comprehend. Intolerance is responsible for the mock lynching Bakchos was subjected to last Easter.

Intolerance yes, but it is so much more than just racism. At the base of racism is the pure, ugly truth – power. I said it in my poem earlier:

… There cannot be a master race if contamination be
All power, all truth, survival lies with no-one else but me!

Commissioner Scipione, Peter FitzSimmons and anyone else with their hand on the steering wheel of justice or power and a voice to rally commonsense, I am in complete agreeance with you about the image set on Saturday and the setback to inter-racial relations. But I am not with you when it comes to the two-faced manner in which Australia has managed the racism within its own border. Peter FitzSimmon, go do an investigative article on what happened to Pat. You’re a researcher, you’re a story-teller. Do you have the guts? Do you have the guts to peel open the rancid innards of the country that professes to want to Close the Gap but has marginalized some of its hardest working Indigenous people?

I have grown to despair for integrity, for I believe that it does not exist in this country any longer. The people who lead this country no longer have a sense of right and hence cannot act consistently with truth. The rule of law is little more than rhetoric; I see the evidence daily. Take the victims king-hit in the streets on a Friday night who see their assailants walk away with a good behaviour bond while their broken jaw, concussion or spinal injuries leave lifelong damage. Take the gutter tactics used by so-called lawyers, politicians and employers intent upon not truth or justice, but a win at any cost, no matter how many people they hurt. Forgiveness for failures and transgressions is possible, but there comes a point beyond which the repetition of such failures and the excuses for bad behaviour cease to be excusable. After ten years, I think the failures of the multitudes that sacrificed Pat are no longer excusable and that this country has bred the discord within its own borders that so worryingly raised its head this weekend. Monkey see, monkey do.


  1. Some good points about race and the need to drive race relations forward in Australia.

  2. Hannah says:

    “I told you Australia”… but how to make them listen?

  3. You really can’t blame people for their unreasonable conduct when our leaders are no better and in fact in many ways are much worse. Australia you must listen, and not only listen, but you must act on the issue of race.

  4. What happened in Sydney is unacceptable, but as an Indigenous woman I can understand why those on the margins of Australian society may see violence as their only real voice.

  5. Phillipa Coe as an Indigenous Australian Male I also share your views on the why those Australians on the margins of society may see the need to turn to violence as an outlet for their frustrations.

  6. Phillipa Coe and Mick Donaldson I get your point, but there is never an excuse for the violence that happened in Sydney over the weekend.

  7. Guys I can’t see that there ever can be an excuse for the type of violence we witnessed in Sydney over the weekend. Phillipa Coe and Mick Donaldson I take your points, but violence is unacceptable.

  8. The following is the text of a letter to the editor appearing in todays SMH: Calling all Muslims, Christians, Jews, Hindus, atheists, etc: Let’s organise a religious tolerance march where we can celebrate and reinforce those values that 99 per cent of us all hold dear – love, peace, tolerance, being Australian. I would love to march arm-in-arm with anyone of any religious or non-religious persuasion who shares these values under banners proclaiming love for each other and perhaps a barbecue in Hyde Park to follow. Next Australia Day?

    David Peter North Narrabeen

  9. Hello Tamara Ann Wooden the SMH letter you posted puts it all in perspective.

  10. The problem with the the arguments about what is acceptable and not in the community is that those in authority ignore the rules, so how can they expect the rest of the community to follow what they themselves refuse to follow? For rules to work they MUST apply equally to all.

  11. The lesson here is that people won’t respect the laws of the land unless those making the laws respect them first. Whilst I don’t condone the violence in Sydney over the weekend, I can understand the frustration behind it.

  12. The lesson for our leaders is that Australia has changed and unless leadership follows the change, well there will be more unrest, more destruction and more injury. Racism and the White Australia Policy are dead and buried. It’s time for accountability and leadership. Who’s up for the challenge?

  13. There are lessons from what happened over the weekend, not the least of which is the price we will all pay as a community unless our leaders start to show some real leadership in the area of race relatiins.

  14. Niles there are indeed lessons, read todays post, hopefully the lessons will kick in before its way too late.

  15. Follow our leaders right down the shitter! way to go Oz!

  16. In reality all that happened over the weekend was that some Muslim citizens decided to play follow the leader!

  17. Perhaps if our so called leaders showed some leadership things like what happened on the weekend would not. people don’t do this kind of thing without a reason.

  18. Ah the monkey theory, the protests in Sydney over the weekend were as much about frustration with Australia’s racist policies as they were about religion.

  19. Anne Shiny via Facebook says:

    Paulo Flores, your double entendre amuses me!

  20. Anne a jocular response to a serious issue never hurts

  21. Muslim youth see corruption, Muslim youth take issues to the streets, Australia’s corruption is comming back to bite us all on the arse.

  22. Mahmud Ahsan via Facebook says:

    Yes Watershedd Monkes does do what he sees, ahd after all what are we humans but a species on monkey!

  23. Its high time that our leaders started showing some real leadership and held themselves accountable for their actions.

  24. If our leaders set a bad example, others will follow that lead!

  25. Absolutly monkey does what monkey sees, just ask the Inquisitor!

  26. If the media stopped attacking Islam and other minority groups the reason for the social unrest would probably cease to be.

  27. People will generally follow what they see, not what they are told to see.

  28. Monkey follow the leader, problem is Australia has such poor leaders, only trouble can follow from that.

  29. Obviously ain’t no black monkey’s here because we can think for ourselves! Only whitie racist shits play follow the monkey!!!

Leave a Comment

This blog is kept spam free by WP-SpamFree.